Let φ=1+√52 be the golden ratio.
For every positive integer n≥2, show that there is exactly one way to write 1 as the sum
n∑i=1φ−ai
where a1<a2<⋯<an are n distinct positive integers
For eg:
1=φ−1+φ−2=φ−1+φ−3+φ−4
We will start with a few Lemmas.
Let t=φ−1 and we will use powers of t for convenience.
Lemma 0: tk=tk+1+tk+2,∀k≥0
Proof: Easy to see.
Lemma 1: For every n≥1,
1=t2n+n∑j=1t2j−1
Proof:
We get
t2n+n∑j=1t2j−1=t2n+t2n−1+n−1∑j=1t2j−1
=t2n−2+n−1∑j=1t2j−1
(by applying lemma 0)
By using induction, and 1=t+t2, we are done.
Lemma 2: If a1<a2<a3⋯<an are n distinct positive integers such that ai+1<ai+1,1≤i<n (i.e, there aren't consecutive numbers in the ai), then
n∑j=1taj<1
Proof:
If am∈{2k−1,2k} then tam≤t2k−1
Since no ais are consecutive
n∑j=1taj<∞∑k=1t2k−1=1
Now for the main result.
Proposition: Given a positive integer n≥2, there is exactly one way to write 1 as the sum
1=n∑j=1taj
where a1<a2⋯<an are n distinct positive integers.
Proof:
By Lemma 1, we see that there is at least one way.
For n=2 it is easy to see the uniqueness.
We now prove by induction on n.
Assume uniqueness for n.
Now suppose
1=n+1∑j=1taj
with a1<a2<⋯<an+1.
By Lemma 2, there is some i such that ai+1=ai+1.
Let i be the least i such that ai+1=ai+1. Note that i>1 (otherwise the whole sum = t+t2+⋯>1).
By Lemma 0, we have that tai−1=tai+tai+1. Since i was the least i, there is no j such that aj=ai−1.
Thus, we now have a representation using n terms
a1<a2<ai−1<ai−1<ai+2<⋯<an+1
By induction hypothesis this representation is unique, which must be as written in Lemma 1 and must be the same as
1<3<5⋯<2n−3<2n−2
If the newly created term ai−1 is one of 1,3,5,…,2n−3, then we must have ai+1=ai+2 which is not possible.
Hence we see that the original representation using n+1 terms be
1<3<5<⋯<2n−3<2n−1<2n
No comments:
Post a Comment