Processing math: 100%

Monday, February 10, 2025

Writing 1 as the sum of golden ratio reciprocal powers

 Let φ=1+52 be the golden ratio.


For every positive integer n2, show that there is exactly one way to write 1 as the sum


ni=1φai


where a1<a2<<an are n distinct positive integers


For eg:


1=φ1+φ2=φ1+φ3+φ4






We will start with a few Lemmas.


Let t=φ1 and we will use powers of t for convenience.

Lemma 0: tk=tk+1+tk+2,k0

Proof: Easy to see.  

Lemma 1: For every n1

1=t2n+nj=1t2j1

Proof

We get 

t2n+nj=1t2j1=t2n+t2n1+n1j=1t2j1

=t2n2+n1j=1t2j1

(by applying lemma 0)

By using induction, and 1=t+t2, we are done.

Lemma 2: If a1<a2<a3<an are n distinct positive integers such that ai+1<ai+1,1i<n  (i.e, there aren't consecutive numbers in the ai), then

nj=1taj<1

Proof:

If am{2k1,2k} then tamt2k1

Since no ais are consecutive

nj=1taj<k=1t2k1=1


Now for the main result.

Proposition: Given a positive integer n2, there is exactly one way to write 1 as the sum 

1=nj=1taj

where a1<a2<an are n distinct positive integers.

Proof:

By Lemma 1, we see that there is at least one way.

For n=2 it is easy to see the uniqueness.

We now prove by induction on n.

 Assume uniqueness for n.

Now suppose

1=n+1j=1taj

with a1<a2<<an+1.

By Lemma 2, there is some i such that ai+1=ai+1.

Let i be the least i such that ai+1=ai+1. Note that i>1 (otherwise the whole sum = t+t2+>1).

By Lemma 0, we have that tai1=tai+tai+1. Since i was the least i, there is no j such that aj=ai1.

Thus, we now have a representation using n terms

a1<a2<ai1<ai1<ai+2<<an+1

By induction hypothesis this representation is unique, which must be as written in Lemma 1 and must be the same as 

1<3<5<2n3<2n2


If the newly created term ai1 is one of 1,3,5,,2n3, then we must have ai+1=ai+2 which is not possible.

Hence we see that the original representation using n+1 terms be

1<3<5<<2n3<2n1<2n

No comments:

Post a Comment