Loading [MathJax]/jax/output/HTML-CSS/jax.js

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Solution to the Chain of Sets puzzle

[This is a solution to the Chain of Sets puzzle posted earlier]

A brief description of the problem:

Is there an uncountable set F of subsets of N such that for any distinct A,BF either AB or BA?

Solution


A solution uses the fact that the dense set of rationals Q is countable i.e. there is some numbering of the rationals as Q={q1,q2,q3,}
For each real number r, let Qr be the set of rationals strictly less than r.

Each such Qr={qi1,qi2,qi3,} can be associated with a subset of naturals (by taking the subscripts) Nr={i1,i2,i3,}
If y<x, then we have NyNx. Since the rationals are dense, NxNy.

So the answer is, yes, there is an uncountable set with the required property: F={Nr:rR}

No comments:

Post a Comment